Description
Valentine’s Day Math Mystery 1st Grade: The Case of the Heartbroken Heroes is a no-prep Valentine’s Day math review for 1st Grade students. It is a math review of addition, subtraction, and number sense with a superhero twist. Students use their math skills to unlock clues, then use their powers of deduction to narrow down the list of suspects and rescue the kidnapped pets. It is useful for a fun spiral math review session.
The Story: The Case of the Heartbroken Heroes
A villain has stolen the characters’ beloved pets, causing their hearts to break! It’s a rescue mission: math detectives must solve the clues to find the culprit and rescue the pets.
Set the scene with the optional video hook for the Case of the Heartbroken Heroes on your whiteboard or screen, then wrap up the case with the ending video. Students solve the math worksheets to unlock clues and eliminate possibilities after each clue to crack the case.
Math Skills Required to Unlock Clues
There are five clues to crack to solve the mystery:
- Clue 1: Adding Three Addends (Single Digits only)
- Clue 2: Comparing Numbers between 1-99
- Clue 3: Greater than or less than 50
- Clue 4: Subtract a single digit (1-5) from a double-digit number (no regrouping) – Vertical algorithm format
- Clue 5: Subtract ten from double-digit numbers – Vertical algorithm format
Students must use critical thinking skills to work out what each clue is telling them to eliminate from the list of possibilities.
What is Included in this Math Mystery?
- Optional video hook to introduce the case (watch it here).
- Ending video to wrap up the case.
- Printable PDF case file: the mystery story, suspect list, and five clue worksheets.
- Digital option: a Word document in the download contains a Google link to share this resource with your students via Google Classroom or Drive.
- Google Slides note: you will need to make a copy of the Google Slides to your drive before you can edit. Parts of the pages are editable so that your students can complete them without having to print the pages.
- PowerPoint version: the worksheets as a slide deck with editable text boxes for Microsoft users.
- Printable awards to celebrate your detectives.
- Complete answer key.
Easy prep: Print the student pages, staple or place them in a folder, and your students are ready to start. Or assign the digital version for a paperless option.
Valentine’s Day Math Mystery 1st Grade: Who It Is For
This edition is written for 1st Grade students and works in the weeks leading up to Valentine’s Day (or any time in February). Use it for:
- Independent, pairs, or group work
- Math centers
- Your sub tub
- Early finisher tasks
- Homework
- Classroom practice and review sessions
Pacing and Timing: Time to complete will vary anywhere between 30 minutes and 2 hours or more. It mainly depends on how familiar your students are with the math mystery format, and how difficult they find the math skills covered in the clues. Please check the skills above to help determine suitability for your class.
I recommend pacing this activity by giving students one clue at a time. Once the whole class has completed a clue, move on to the next clue, either within the same lesson or in the next math session. New math content presented? Make a lesson out of it by modeling the math before diving into the clue. I like to say, “We must learn something new before attempting the next clue.”
Suggestion: Pace the clues one by one to keep the class at the same point. If using the clues in a different order, keep the suspect list away from students until all five clues are completed and discovered.
This Math Mystery is also available in a CSI Digital Mystery Game format that can be played on any device with an Internet connection. The game option contains more graphics and is not the same style as the digital worksheets provided in the printable packets.
You may also like:
Easy Grade-Level Differentiation
The Case of the Heartbroken Heroes is available in 6 grade editions. The story is the same; the math is different, so you can match each group to its level:
- Kindergarten Edition (special 5 W’s cut-and-paste format)
- 2nd Grade Edition
- 3rd Grade Edition
- 4th Grade Edition
- 5th Grade Edition
Grades 2 and up can “clue swap” between editions to differentiate within one class. Kindergarten editions use the 5 W’s format and Grade 1 Math Mysteries are formatted for early learners, so these cannot be clue-swapped with the other grade versions. Read more: How to differentiate using Math Mysteries.
More Valentine’s Day and February Math for 1st Grade
- Valentine’s Day Math Mystery 1st Grade: The Case of the Vanishing Valentines
- Valentine’s Day Math Mystery 1st Grade: The Case of the Valentine Villain
- Groundhog Day Math Mystery 1st Grade: The Case of the Kidnapped Groundhog
- 1st Grade Valentine’s Day Mini Math Mysteries
Skills and Common Core Standards
- 1.OA.A.2 – Solve word problems that call for addition of three whole numbers (adding three single-digit addends)
- 1.NBT.B.3 – Compare two two-digit numbers using the symbols >, =, and < (comparing numbers 1-99; greater or less than 50)
- 1.NBT.C.5 – Mentally find 10 more or 10 less than a two-digit number (subtracting ten from double-digit numbers)
Looking for more? The Case of the Heartbroken Heroes is part of the 1st Grade Math Mystery Bundle, if you’d like a full set of resources in one place.
Not sure what a math mystery is? Read What is a Math Mystery? on my blog, or watch a short video about Math Mysteries.
Add extra motivation with the free Detective Rank Chart and Mystery Record. New to math mysteries? Try the free Case of the Super Bad Superhero first.
FAQ
Is there any regrouping involved?
No. 1st graders are often just learning place value, so Clue 4 focuses on subtraction without regrouping (e.g., 25 – 4) to build confidence.
What is “Subtracting Ten”?
Clue 5 targets Standard 1.NBT.C.5 (given a two-digit number, mentally find 10 less). This helps students master the patterns in the hundreds chart.
Does this work with the other grade levels?
While the story is the same as the other grade versions, the 1st Grade puzzles are unique and cannot be “clue swapped” with the older grades. This keeps the math age-appropriate.
Is an answer key included?
Yes. A complete answer key is included, along with printable awards.
Can I use this with other grades?
Yes. The Case of the Heartbroken Heroes comes in 6 grade editions with the same story and different math, so you can match the edition to your students.
Technical issues? See my Troubleshooting Tips and FAQ page, or email me at jjresourcecreations@gmail.com.
For more ideas, activities, and resources, follow my store to stay updated on new releases. We can also stay connected via:
- Subscribe to my newsletter and blog
- Instagram @mrsjsresourcecreations
- Follow me on TPT
Thank you!
Jacqui J.
Mrs. J’s Resource Creations




Reviews
There are no reviews yet.