Description
Bring autumn excitement and critical thinking into your classroom with this FREE September Logic Puzzle, the Apple Picking Mini-Mystery! Designed to build deductive reasoning, reading comprehension, and problem-solving stamina, this fall-themed grid activity turns logic into an engaging orchard mystery.
Students use 7 targeted clue statements to eliminate possibilities on a structured grid, determining which child (Gwen, Hank, Iris, Jon, or Kyle) picked which variety of apple (Fuji, Gala, Granny Smith, Honeycrisp, or McIntosh) and how many apples were in their basket (10, 20, 30, 40, or 50).
What’s Included
- Apple Picking Mini-Mystery Student Worksheet: complete with a clean logic grid and a practical “Tips” box that guides students through using ticks and crosses to make systematic discoveries.
- Full Answer Key: clear, quick verification for teacher grading or student self-checking.
- No Prep Required: simply print and distribute!
Educational Benefits
- Critical Thinking: students must analyze clues, make logical deductions, and cross-reference information.
- Reading Comprehension: careful reading is required to catch the subtle hints hidden within the clues.
- Persistence: encourages students to stay focused on a “brain-buster” task.
Who This September Logic Puzzle Is For
Use it for:
- September Morning Work: set a focused, calm tone for the school day with a quick deductive warm-up.
- Fast Finishers: keep eager students purposefully engaged without creating extra grading.
- Math & Logic Centers: incorporate critical thinking stations into your regular rotation.
- Sub Tub Essential: an easy, zero-prep activity any substitute teacher can implement immediately.
Easy prep: Just print and go.
Expand the Mystery!
Love classroom mysteries? Expand the adventure into your core curriculum with the Case of the September Sillies! In this full-scale Math Mystery investigation, students practice essential grade-level skills to unlock clues and uncover the secret recipe for the cure after a silly virus spreads across Mathhattan. Watch the video hook.
Check out my other September resources:
- September Math Mystery 1st Grade Activity: September Sillies
- September Math Mystery 2nd Grade Activity: September Sillies
- September Math Mystery 3rd Grade Activity: September Sillies
- September Math Mystery 4th Grade Activity: September Sillies
- September Math Mystery 5th Grade Activity: September Sillies
- September Math Mystery 6th Grade Activity: September Sillies
- Labor Day Math Mystery 1st Grade Activity: ‘Construction Conundrum’
- Labor Day Math Mystery 2nd Grade Activity: ‘Construction Conundrum’
- Labor Day Math Mystery 3rd Grade Activity: ‘Construction Crew Conundrum’
- Labor Day Math Mystery 4th Grade Activity: ‘Construction Crew’
- Labor Day 5th Grade Math Mystery Worksheets: Construction Crew
- Labor Day Math Mystery 6th Grade Activity: ‘Construction Conundrum’
More September and Fall Fun
- Labor Day Word Search Puzzle (free)
- Back to School Logic Puzzle: The School Bus (free)
- Browse all Back to School resources
- More free logic puzzles
Skills and Common Core Standards
- MP1 – Make sense of problems and persevere in solving them
- MP3 – Construct viable arguments and critique the reasoning of others
FAQ
Is it free?
Yes. Just print and go.
Is an answer key included?
Yes, an answer key is provided for quick and easy grading.
What do students need to work out?
Which child (Gwen, Hank, Iris, Jon, or Kyle) picked which variety of apple (Fuji, Gala, Granny Smith, Honeycrisp, or McIntosh) and how many apples were in their basket (10, 20, 30, 40, or 50), using the 7 clues and the logic grid.
Technical issues? See my Troubleshooting Tips and FAQ page, or email me at jjresourcecreations@gmail.com.
Thank you so much for your wonderful support! I am so grateful to have you using these resources in your classroom.
For more ideas, activities, and resources, follow my store to stay updated on new releases. We can also stay connected via:
- Subscribe to my newsletter and blog
- Instagram @mrsjsresourcecreations
- Follow me on TPT
Thank you!
Jacqui J.
Mrs. J’s Resource Creations


Reviews
There are no reviews yet.