Quick Answer: A Free One-Page Halloween Math Mystery for K–5
The Case of the Broomstick Burglar is a free Halloween Mini Math Mystery with six grade editions, from Kindergarten to 5th grade. Students complete the math on a single page and use their answers to work out who the Broomstick Burglar is. Each edition has the same story and suspects, but the math (and the thief!) is different in every version.
Math shouldn’t be scary, especially around Halloween. But sometimes, no matter how many manipulatives or activities you try, getting kids engaged in math time can feel like more of a trick than a treat. If you are looking for an easy way to make math fun this October, this freebie is quick to prep and fun to solve.
Download Your Free Grade Edition
- Kindergarten Edition: Counting with ten frames (objects 1–10)
- 1st Grade Edition: Addition within 15 (number line included)
- 2nd Grade Edition: Adding 2-digit numbers (no regrouping)
- 3rd Grade Edition: Addition within 1,000 (with regrouping)
- 4th Grade Edition: Identifying factors
- 5th Grade Edition: Comparing decimals
Each download includes:
- A printable mini-mystery page
- A link to open the mini-mystery in Google Slides to complete digitally
- An answer key, so you can quickly check for understanding
- Optional printable awards to give to your amazing student detectives
How Mini Math Mysteries Work
Mini Math Mysteries are a fun, game-like, one-page activity. They are a condensed version of a mystery with a simple elimination structure: students use their answers to eliminate possibilities. The story is short (a couple of sentences to a paragraph), and unlike my full Math Mysteries, there are no clue messages or video hooks. They are designed for teachers who want something quick and short that still feels fun.
- Morning work or warm-ups during Halloween week
- Math centers and early finishers
- Differentiation: because every edition shares the same story, you can hand out different grade editions to different math groups
Want More? Try the 10-Mystery Halloween Packs
If your students want more of these tricky math treats, each grade has a Halloween Mini Math Mysteries pack with TEN mini mysteries in printable and digital (Google Slides) formats: K, 1st, 2nd, 3rd, 4th, 5th.
More Free Halloween Fun
- The free Halloween Costume Party Logic Puzzle
- Free Halloween arcade games: Phantom Pumpkin Prankster, Haunted Candy Heist, Potion Cauldron, and Mummy Math Tomb Dash
- Halloween Math Word Problem Prompt Cards (free)
- 10 Free Halloween Math Games Kids Will Love
FAQ
Is The Case of the Broomstick Burglar really free?
Yes. All six grade editions are free downloads.
Can I use it on devices?
Yes. Each download includes a link to a Google Slides version that students can complete digitally.
Is the culprit the same in every grade?
No. The story and suspects are the same, but each version has different math and a different thief.