Are you using our Earth Day Math Mystery: The Case of the Litterbug as part of your spring or Earth Day math sessions? It has been a classroom favorite for years, and every April I hear from teachers whose students love the story—but occasionally get tripped up by the tricky wording revealed in Clue 1!
Because this clue requires a two-step logical deduction rather than a simple word match, it is a fantastic teachable moment for critical thinking. Here is a quick, step-by-step guide you can share with your class if Clue 1 causes any confusion.
Here’s Where Detectives Get Tricked in Clue 1
Once your students finish the math problems on the Clue 1 worksheet, they crack the code to reveal this message:Clue 1 Revealed: “Most of the mess is happening at night.”
Now, students look at their Possible Suspects List, which shows a column indicating whether each suspect sleeps during the Day or at Night.
| Suspect Trait on List | What It Means at Night (When the Crime Happens) | Keep or Cross Off? |
|---|---|---|
| Sleeps in the Night | Fast asleep in bed while the littering happens! | CROSS OFF (Cannot be the Litterbug) |
| Sleeps in the Day | Wide awake at night when the mess is made! | KEEP (Still a possible suspect) |
Ask Your Students: What Do You Cross Off the List?
Pose this question to your class before they touch their pencils:
- Cross off all suspects who sleep in the day
- Cross off all suspects who sleep in the night
Think about it…
You are spot on if you answered #2: Cross off all suspects who sleep in the night!
Here’s Why:
If most of the littering is happening at night, then the Litterbug must be awake at night—meaning the culprit cannot be a character who is fast asleep at night! Therefore, the culprit must be one of the daytime sleepers (nocturnal characters). Detectives must cross off all of the nighttime sleepers and keep the daytime sleepers on the suspect list.
Finishing the Case
Once Clue 1 is complete, students continue working through Clues 2, 3, 4, and 5 to narrow down the remaining suspects for the Litterbug until only one culprit remains!
Remember that clues must be completed in order (1 to 5). For the smoothest classroom experience, I recommend handing out clue worksheets one by one rather than giving the entire packet at once (see our Top 5 Math Mystery Mistakes to Avoid for more pacing tips).
Explore the Earth Day Math Mystery (“The Case of the Litterbug”)
You can grab The Case of the Litterbug right here on our website (including the Case of the Litterbug Video Hook to set the stage!). Remember, Grades 2–6 share the exact same story and clues, so you can easily swap clues across grade levels to differentiate:
- Earth Day Math Mystery — Kindergarten Edition
- Earth Day Math Mystery — 3rd Grade Edition
- Earth Day Math Mystery — 4th Grade Edition
- Earth Day Math Mystery — 5th Grade Edition
- Earth Day Math Mystery — 6th Grade Edition
- Earth Day Math Mystery — 8th Grade Edition

